PUBLISHER: IDW (2012-2013)
WRITER: JAMES ROBERTS
ARTISTS: ALEX MILNE, BRENDAN CAHILL, GUIDO GUIDI, AGUSTIN PADILLA
There's a question deep in the heart of James Roberts' writing which boils down to one issue - is it worth short-term frustration for a long-term payoff? It's a difficult one; the quality of the payoff plays a big part but so does the nature of the frustration. Throughout the first three volumes (which amount to about a year's worth of comics, which is one Watchmen) it's been pretty clear that everyone we've seen far too much of is part of some grander plan and in the fourth collection things finally begin paying off. Partly. For some characters.
Showing posts with label Guido Guidi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Guido Guidi. Show all posts
Sunday, 7 May 2017
Saturday, 6 May 2017
Comic Review: Transformers - Robots in Disguise, Volume 3
PUBLISHER: IDW (2012)
WRITER: JOHN BARBER
ARTISTS: BRENDAN CAHILL, GUIDO GUIDI, LIVIO RAMONDELLI
The third collection of Robots in Disguise again suffers from the difficulty IDW had from lining up trades properly with the writers; why they haven't gone for a fixed six-issue trade length with the creative teams free to divide each block up as they see fit I don't know. Money, money, money I guess, unless there was some demand for multiple pages of sketches that pushed the stories down readers' wishlists. The third trade for RID is possibly the most fractured volume yet - containing the Annual, a one-shot catching back up with Orion Pax and another part of "Combiner Wars".
WRITER: JOHN BARBER
ARTISTS: BRENDAN CAHILL, GUIDO GUIDI, LIVIO RAMONDELLI
The third collection of Robots in Disguise again suffers from the difficulty IDW had from lining up trades properly with the writers; why they haven't gone for a fixed six-issue trade length with the creative teams free to divide each block up as they see fit I don't know. Money, money, money I guess, unless there was some demand for multiple pages of sketches that pushed the stories down readers' wishlists. The third trade for RID is possibly the most fractured volume yet - containing the Annual, a one-shot catching back up with Orion Pax and another part of "Combiner Wars".
Labels:
2012,
Brendan Cahill,
Comic,
Guido Guidi,
IDW,
John Barber,
Livio Ramondelli,
Robots in Disguise,
TPB,
Transformers
Thursday, 4 May 2017
Comic Review: Transformers - More Than Meets the Eye, Volume 3
PUBLISHER: IDW (2012)
WRITER: JAMES ROBERTS
ARTISTS: JIMBO SALGADO, EMIL CABALTIERRA, GUIDO GUIDI, ALEX MILNE
Comic annuals are a funny thing usually; not the hardbacked volumes that result in so much shared cultural memories in the UK, but the American comic version - a double or triple length issue which had to come out alongside the monthly book and avoid clashing with the monthly issues it was ran alongside while having some sort of point. Quite why IDW decided to revive the format I don't know, though they were at least able to keep the writers on both even if the artists couldn't fit it into their schedules. The third MTMTE trade collects that title's annual and the three-part "Shadowplay" story that was James Roberts' solution to the Optimus Prime mandate received from Hasbro. Both show him at his strongest and weakest.
WRITER: JAMES ROBERTS
ARTISTS: JIMBO SALGADO, EMIL CABALTIERRA, GUIDO GUIDI, ALEX MILNE
Comic annuals are a funny thing usually; not the hardbacked volumes that result in so much shared cultural memories in the UK, but the American comic version - a double or triple length issue which had to come out alongside the monthly book and avoid clashing with the monthly issues it was ran alongside while having some sort of point. Quite why IDW decided to revive the format I don't know, though they were at least able to keep the writers on both even if the artists couldn't fit it into their schedules. The third MTMTE trade collects that title's annual and the three-part "Shadowplay" story that was James Roberts' solution to the Optimus Prime mandate received from Hasbro. Both show him at his strongest and weakest.
Tuesday, 18 April 2017
Comic Review: Transformers - Chaos Theory
PUBLISHER: IDW (2011)
WRITERS: MIKE COSTA, JAMES ROBERTS
ARTISTS: GUIDO GUIDI, ALEX MILNE
The supreme irony of IDW finally taking the plunge into making a single Transformers ongoing only for it to be even more fractured continues in the fifth collection of the series. IDW had by now realised that Mike Costa wasn't really hitting the right notes with either the fandom or the by this stage non-existent casual readers the title had accrued and began looking at bringing in another writer alongside the handful, the original plan being for Dan Abnett & Andy Lanning to join the three or four different Mike Costas in writing the book. After contributing the dodgy "Infestation" and weird "Heart of Darkness", the first building blocks for the planned "Chaos" event storyline, yet another IDW saga that would make sure the world of Transformers would never be the same or whatever. They then fucked off to do something else and instead the job went to James Roberts, then just the popular mortal writer of Last Stand of the Wreckers and yet to be cocooned in a sycophantic social media echo chamber.
WRITERS: MIKE COSTA, JAMES ROBERTS
ARTISTS: GUIDO GUIDI, ALEX MILNE
The supreme irony of IDW finally taking the plunge into making a single Transformers ongoing only for it to be even more fractured continues in the fifth collection of the series. IDW had by now realised that Mike Costa wasn't really hitting the right notes with either the fandom or the by this stage non-existent casual readers the title had accrued and began looking at bringing in another writer alongside the handful, the original plan being for Dan Abnett & Andy Lanning to join the three or four different Mike Costas in writing the book. After contributing the dodgy "Infestation" and weird "Heart of Darkness", the first building blocks for the planned "Chaos" event storyline, yet another IDW saga that would make sure the world of Transformers would never be the same or whatever. They then fucked off to do something else and instead the job went to James Roberts, then just the popular mortal writer of Last Stand of the Wreckers and yet to be cocooned in a sycophantic social media echo chamber.
Labels:
2011,
Alex Milne,
Comic,
Guido Guidi,
IDW,
James Roberts,
Mike Costa,
TPB,
Transformers
Saturday, 25 March 2017
Comic Review: Transformers - International Incident
PUBLISHER: IDW (2010)
WRITER: MIKE COSTA
ARTISTS: E J SU, JAVIER SALTARES, GUIDO GUIDI
All comic writers have bad ideas. The trick is to realise them as such. The second batch of issues from Mike Costa's unsubtitled ongoing series are an odd bunch. The man has no quality control; not since Bob Budiasnky's second year on the old Marvel title (after which he was obviously trying to get fired) has a writer on Transformers had so many good ideas and so many bad ideas blended with a total inability to realise which is which. The result is bordering on schizophrenia and results in a wildly uneven ride.
WRITER: MIKE COSTA
ARTISTS: E J SU, JAVIER SALTARES, GUIDO GUIDI
All comic writers have bad ideas. The trick is to realise them as such. The second batch of issues from Mike Costa's unsubtitled ongoing series are an odd bunch. The man has no quality control; not since Bob Budiasnky's second year on the old Marvel title (after which he was obviously trying to get fired) has a writer on Transformers had so many good ideas and so many bad ideas blended with a total inability to realise which is which. The result is bordering on schizophrenia and results in a wildly uneven ride.
Labels:
2010,
Comic,
E J Su,
Guido Guidi,
IDW,
Javier Saltares,
Mike Costa,
TPB,
Transformers
Friday, 24 March 2017
Comic Review: Transformers - Last Stand of the Wreckers
PUBLISHER: IDW (2010)
WRITERS: NICK ROCHE, JAMES ROBERTS
ARTISTS: NICK ROCHE, GUIDO GUIDI
It's fair to say that in 2010 people were fed up with IDW. Simon Furman had been given unprecedented control and freedom when the publisher got the licence at the fag-end of 2005 and squandered it with a meandering three-year pile-up of dreadful storylines. Replacing him with Shane McCarthy upset the deluded who felt Furman's work was ever going to go anywhere and then upset the people who were up for a change when his All Hail Megatron arc rapidly went from being stupid fun to stupid stupid, and then successor Mike Costa's tenure got off to a very wobbly start. Something was needed to get the fans onside; the result was the recalling of fan-turned writer-artist Nick Roche, whose debut on Spotlight - Kup had been one of the few universally acclaimed pieces of output since IDW picked the licence up. Roche then roped in fellow Transmasters alumni James Roberts to help out on the script, to focus entirely on the Wreckers.
WRITERS: NICK ROCHE, JAMES ROBERTS
ARTISTS: NICK ROCHE, GUIDO GUIDI
It's fair to say that in 2010 people were fed up with IDW. Simon Furman had been given unprecedented control and freedom when the publisher got the licence at the fag-end of 2005 and squandered it with a meandering three-year pile-up of dreadful storylines. Replacing him with Shane McCarthy upset the deluded who felt Furman's work was ever going to go anywhere and then upset the people who were up for a change when his All Hail Megatron arc rapidly went from being stupid fun to stupid stupid, and then successor Mike Costa's tenure got off to a very wobbly start. Something was needed to get the fans onside; the result was the recalling of fan-turned writer-artist Nick Roche, whose debut on Spotlight - Kup had been one of the few universally acclaimed pieces of output since IDW picked the licence up. Roche then roped in fellow Transmasters alumni James Roberts to help out on the script, to focus entirely on the Wreckers.
Labels:
2010,
Comic,
Guido Guidi,
IDW,
James Roberts,
Mini Series,
Nick Roche,
Transformers,
Wreckers
Thursday, 28 January 2016
Comic Review - Transformers: All Hail Megatron
PUBLISHER: IDW, 2008-2009
WRITER: SHANE MCCARTHY
ARTIST: GUIDO GUIDI, CASEY COLLER, E.J. SU, ROBERT DEAS, EMILIANO SANTALUCIA
All Hail Megatron
gets so much right. So, so much. Intended as a summer blockbuster to
reconnect with the casual comic buyer, long alienated by the rambling
joyless mess Simon Furman had turned the book into AHM largely failed from both a commercial and critical point of view.
The basic idea of resetting the cast to all the big names and having Megatron
straight up invade Earth is great. After the Reapers and the Dead
Universe and Verity and all those moronic Men in Black operations
readers were due some good wholesome smashy robot fun. It even follows on nicely from the Autobots abandoning Earth abruptly in Devastation while the protracted winding down of Furman's storylines largely involved putting all the familiar faces in the familiar places.
And the opening setup is great, with the Decepticons wreaking unchecked havoc in New York while the Autobots huddle on a habitable but inhospitable Cybertron, with Optimus
Prime on life support after they were lured into a trap by an unknown
traitor. There's some surprisingly adept characterisation in there as
well, ranging from good takes on Ironhide and Cliffjumper to the first real progression of the Megatron/Starscream dynamic since, well, ever.
But
right from the start there are problems. Firstly the series is straight
up overlong. The plot would have been nice brainless popcorn fodder at
six issues (which I recall it was originally pitched as); at twelve
issues it's flabby and bloated. Most dispensable are the humans - while
some idea of the natives' response and predicament was necessary the
time and space given over to first downed F22 pilot Andy and then IDW's in-name-only arsehole version of Spike Witwicky not only sap the pace but in the case of the latter take away plausibility too.
Secondly McCarthy cheats somewhat on bringing further characters into things. The basic premise revolves around the Autobots having taken serious military reverses all over the universe. This takes a hit when the battered squad on Cybertron get an artificial pepping up due to Kup and a crew of guys the writer obviously thinks are the coolest ones just drop in and start showing off. Yes, Science Sniper Perceptor
is cool but their arrival just feels like a cheap shot - and when Omega
Supreme makes a timely reappearance suspense disappears as it becomes
clear there's always going to be a cheap escape route. Kup
himself is also quite annoying - the Gunnery Sergeant Hartman
impression wears thin quickly and rather than coming across as an
inspiring living legend he's more of a grousing, bossy sod.
Thirdly there's the odd relationship with past material where some of Furman's
plots are worked on while others are brushed over or outright
contradicted. The discontinuity is jarring due to never really knowing
what's going to be ignored and what's going to be picked up as a plot
point. A straight reboot was clearly the thing to do; quite why IDW opted to shackle the thing to Furman's messy overcomplicated output is one to ponder.
Nothing really sums up the best and worst of All Hail Megatron than the sequence where Sunstreaker is revealed to be the traitor who sold the Autobots out. It's a surprise even though the misdirection afforded to suspecting Mirage is a bit obvious. It's brave - there's no cerebro-shell flaking, with only a little misleading from Starscream an Autobot
betrayed his faction, partly through wanting an end to the war but
largely to dick Earth over after having such a horrible time there.
Which is an odd one as his treatment by the Machination was from Furman's material but then so apparently was some trite rehabilitation. We'll give that a pass as the Huntstreaker
stuff was bilge, though. So let's digest this massive development. ..
No, wait, he's just blown himself up in a dumb redemptive and somewhat
pointless gesture and the whole thing is barely touched upon.
By
the last two or three issues the thing is really all over the place,
still full of padding but also glossing over loads of other things as it
staggers to the finish line. Spike takes up pages and pages while he
finds a supergun to shoot Megatron but at the same time Optimus Prime is revived, the Autobots hop onboard Omega Supreme (in Sunbow mode rather than mystical Spotlight : Optimus Prime mode), fly to Earth in short order and... just beat up the Decepticons. No mention that only a short time ago they were broken husks starving on Cybertron. No big cool strategy, no plot device even. They just drop out of the sky over New York and take the Decepticons out. It is made a little easier by there only being a dozen or so Decepticons; the (possibly Hasbro-mandated) appearance of Dropshot aside, we're in pre-TF:TM territory here, which is odd when you consider who the Autobots have. It makes you wonder, ambush or not, how they managed to lose so badly in the first place.
All Hail Megatron
reads like a first draft of a potentially enjoyable comic. There are
several good moments and in among the attempts at crowd pleasing there
are a couple of genuinely fresh ideas that deserve more exploration in a
better comic. But the finished material is badly paced, contradictory
and ultimately frustrating.
■■■□□□□□□□
Labels:
2008,
2009,
Casey Coller,
Comic,
E J Su,
Emiliano Santalucia,
Guido Guidi,
IDW,
Robert Deas,
Shane McCarthy,
Transformers
Tuesday, 5 January 2016
Transformers - Spotlight: Mirage
Oookay. Spotlight: Mirage is not a bad comic, but I have no idea what it's for. And not in the way that Furman's Spotlights have more than once meandered off on a tangent and further cluttered up the overall story.
The only issue of the third batch of Spotlights not written by Furman, this one was instead penned by George Strayton - an RPG writer who did some hazily defined work on IDW's movie tie-in comics and presumably displayed enough affinity to be given a try-out.
With the main material a complicated mess he was no doubt directed to do something as standalone as possible. The choice of Mirage was probably a matter of finding a character well-known enough to shift a Spotlight but not tied up in Furman's masterplan; as a first year character with a single notable appearance as a murder suspect in Spotlight: Blaster he fits the bill.
The approach to avoiding story discontinuity however is a little odd as the issue either takes place in an alternate timeline of some abstraction or entirely in Mirage's head (though the final page depicting the apparent reality of Mirage driving around Earth as a Ligier is still enough to take this out of mainstream continuity until John Barber apparently found a home for it several years later). The plot mines out the character's apparent flexible loyalties via a dream or fantasy of helping the Decepticons kill the last handful of Autobots in an alternate future that has no particular anchor with the rest of IDW's material. That's a bit of a shame for two reasons.
Firstly, just about the only attention anyone official has ever given him has revolved around whether his sympathies lie. This story takes a slightly different approach by portraying the internal struggle rather than someone (i. e. Cliffjumper ) leaping to conclusions but still, it would be nice if the opportunity had been taken to have a different look at the guy.
Secondly what we see of the alternate or imaginary future is so abstract from everything else that you're spending as much time trying to figure out the purposefully fractured plot at the same time you should be focusing on Mirage. A What If style storyline with Mirage betraying the Autobots at some crucial juncture like the battle in Brasnya would oddly have more impact than the downfall of a group of effective strangers.
Nevertheless taken in isolation it's a nice read, well written and illuminating. The lack of context gives it an odd transcendent feel like the one achieved by the better Mosaics, a universal character study that could ring true for any Mirage. But it's also a dashed odd thing to come out at this point, and it's understandable many readers were nonplussed when it first appeared.
■■■■■■□□□□
Labels:
2008,
Comic,
G1,
George Strayton,
Guido Guidi,
IDW,
Spotlight,
Transformers
Friday, 1 January 2016
Transformers - Spotlight: Galvatron
A couple of thoughts came to me on re-reading this issue which made me think considerably less of the thing.
Firstly there's the superficially fresh idea of having Galvatron himself be a totally different character to Megatron. Despite some minor confusion regarding some promotional material for the Japanese Scramble City OVA back in the early days of fandom and the intentionally non-committal wording of the original toy's Tech Spec (to avoid spoilers for the 1986 film) this has never really been done before. However, when you think about it, it basically has.
Furman's own time travel material for Marvel muddied the water by purposely playing up the pair's differences while having them team up against everyone else and by the time of the second clear cut Galvatron on Furman's American run it's even more abstract. Following Unicron's defeat in "On the Edge of Extinction " that Galvatron becomes a future version of "our" Megatron that can't come to pass in "our" timeline as Cybertron's destruction is averted, or at least the same destruction seen in "Rhythms of Darkness". Which doesn't make that Galvatron a different character, but does lessen the impact here - we're used to situations being contrived to allow Megatron and Galvatron to co-exist.
The Marvel USA Galvatron does bring up a second familiar element of this Spotlight - the character as a reluctant, rebelling herald of a dark force threatening life across the universe - just as he was in relation to Unicron. Now, this might be a little uncharitable (but considering the general quality of Furman's work on IDW I'm not feeling particularly charitable) but isn't Nova Prime actually a lot like Unicron? The heralds, the plan to consume everything, the dire astral warning given to Optimus in Escalation... It might be hard to remember now, but between Dreamwave's output, the potted myths of the Ultimate Guide and the Armada cartoon Transformers fans in general were really getting fed up with Unicron's over-exposure at the time IDW's material got started up and it's worth speculating whether the whole Nova Prime/Dead Universe thing was pitched as a Unicron arc before being overruled and tweaked. Or it could just be that Furman's got a limited imagination when it comes to having a great darkness threatens everyone.
That said, while Galvatron isn't as fresh as he could have been he does at least make an interesting subject, both in terms of his new back story (the idea of him being the one to plunge the Ark-1 into the Dead Universe is a great mirroring of Optimus Prime's fateful decision to set the original Ark on a collision course with Earth in the Marvel series ) and in terms of his resulting personal conflict. His power level is nicely handled too, and it's nice that his agenda to regain his independence for once gives a good reason for him not just killing everyone. As yet the Dead Universe plot is intriguing but it's difficult to get too hyped when there's so much else already going on.
Talking of which the issue takes a page or two to touch base with the Earth plot, establishing that Sunstreaker and Ironhide are still missing after their problems in Escalation and that Verity really deserves to be stepped on. The absence of Sunstreaker leads to the issue's other thread - his brother Sideswipe is stationed at Galvatron's destination (a small pocket of artificial environment on Cybertron) as part of a unit led by Hound guarding Thunderwing's body. Naturally he wants to be posted to Earth to help the search but he's being kept away to keep things simple. Both the fraternal relationship and Sideswipe's character actually deserve more space than this comic can afford them, and it would have been a better use of pages to follow this up than what the next three Spotlights served up.
As it is we get a few frames of introspection before Sideswipe has to battle Galvatron and it's difficult hard to tell if some of the Autobot's dialogue is character work showing he's taking Leadfoot's death personally in response to his brother's disappearance, if Sideswipe and Leadfoot were friends or if it's just bad melodramatic dialogue. The rest of the Autobots get even less space though the redesign of Hound is nice and the Generation 2 fan in me is delighted not only to have Skram and Road Rocket show up but also not dying instantly as cannon fodder.
Overall despite the intended freshness falling flat this is a largely enjoyable read and therefore nudging its' way towards the higher end of Furman's work with the format.
■■■■■■□□□□
Labels:
2007,
Comic,
G1,
Guido Guidi,
IDW,
Simon Furman,
Spotlight,
Transformers
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














